Animal Intelligence Tests

For centuries, researchers have been assessing animal intelligence. As scientific rigor has evolved, so too has skepticism regarding earlier methods, which often lacked adequate controls and statistical backing. The Primate Cognition Test Battery (PCTB), developed by Esther Herrmann, represents a contemporary standard for evaluating animal intelligence. This series of tests presents challenges that require animals to locate rewards, such as food hidden under cups, thereby assessing their spatial memory, understanding of object permanence, numerical reasoning, causality, tool use, and social learning.

Herrmann's findings indicated that a two-and-a-half-year-old child exhibits similar cognitive abilities to a ten-year-old chimpanzee concerning physical comprehension. However, in social contexts, children significantly outperformed both chimpanzees and orangutans. This stark difference suggests that while humans have developed unique social skills for knowledge transmission within cultural groups, these abilities may have evolved from social competencies seen in primates, such as social cognition and learning.

Origins of Animal Intelligence

The question of why primates evolved intelligence has intrigued scientists. Some theorize that brain size increased due to environmental challenges; primates that primarily consume fruit tend to have larger brains than those that eat leaves. Others propose that intelligence evolved in response to complex social dynamics, as seen in basal primates like lemurs, which possess a typical primate society yet lack the advanced manipulation skills found in monkeys.

There is substantial interest in the socially-driven evolution of intelligence, with studies indicating a correlation between the size of a primate's social network and the size of the neocortex, the most recently developed part of the brain. Additionally, the nature of social bonds plays a crucial role, with long-term pair-bonding correlating with a larger neocortex compared to species with transient relationships.

This line of inquiry raises questions about brain size and intelligence in non-primate species that exhibit similar complex social structures. Corvids, including ravens and crows, provide a compelling case, as they have a higher neuron density in their brains compared to primates, potentially accounting for their comparable cognitive abilities.

Comparing Corvids and Apes

Despite extensive research on primates and corvids, a direct comparison using a unified set of tests has been lacking. A recent study published in Nature: Scientific Reports aimed to bridge this gap. Lead author Simone Pika and her team adapted the PCTB for hand-raised ravens, creating the Corvid Cognition Test Battery (CCTB). This adaptation maintained the PCTB's methodology while accommodating the unique traits of ravens.

The study involved eight hand-raised ravens tested at four, eight, twelve, and sixteen months of age. The tests assessed understanding in areas such as causality, quantity, space, communication, and theory of mind. Results showed that the cognitive skills of the ravens remained consistent throughout the study, indicating that their capabilities are fully developed by four months of age.

Ravens demonstrated similar cognitive abilities to chimpanzees and orangutans across both physical and social intelligence, with particularly strong quantitative skills. While researchers anticipated that ravens would excel in social cognition due to their complex social structures, their performance aligned closely with that of great apes.

The first video, "Bird Brain: Smarter Than You Think," explores the surprising cognitive abilities of birds, particularly ravens, and how they might challenge our preconceived notions about intelligence in the animal kingdom.

Important Limitations

The authors of the study acknowledged limitations often overlooked in animal intelligence testing. They noted that the PCTB's division of social and physical intelligence has not been consistently supported by recent analyses of chimpanzee and human data. Pika et al. argued that these forms of intelligence may not have evolved independently but could be closely intertwined.

Furthermore, the social dynamics of ravens, who view each other as both allies and competitors, may influence their performance in tests, as they may perceive human experimenters as rivals for rewards. This competitive nature could overshadow pure intelligence in test outcomes.

The performance of ravens diverged significantly from parrots, which are also recognized for their intelligence but performed at chance levels in tests. Variability in testing conditions and the familiarity of the human testers may significantly impact results.

Ravens excel in tracking the gaze of others, a skill that is critical in their competitive social interactions. Research indicates that ravens can follow the gaze of their peers by eight weeks but require additional time to track human gaze.

While the study suggests similarities in intelligence between ravens and great apes, the authors emphasize that the underlying mechanisms may differ fundamentally. They caution against generalizing the performance of hand-raised ravens to wild populations, recognizing the influence of their specific testing conditions.

Conclusion

Pika et al. concluded that their research provides the first quantitative comparison between ravens and apes, revealing that ravens exhibit comparable physical and social intelligence and develop these skills rapidly. However, they also highlight that the field of animal intelligence testing is still in its infancy and requires further refinement to distinguish genuine intelligence traits from experimental influences, particularly in social species.

In the second video, "Why Bird Brains Are More Brilliant Than Anyone Suspected," the discussion delves into the unexpected intelligence of birds, particularly focusing on their cognitive capacities and social behaviors.

The Apeiron Blog — Big Questions, Made Simple. We understand that philosophy can often seem intricate. To simplify complex topics, we curate informative articles, news, reading lists, and other resources to assist you on your journey. Stay connected with us on Medium and subscribe to our free mailing list.